Pineapple Whip – The pineapple whip cookie tastes like a day at the beach. It has a light and airy taste while still having a bright pineapple flavor. Though sweet, it remains filling but not sickening, and the perfect dessert for spring or summer!
Strawberry Crumb Cake – This week’s strawberry flavor was the fan favorite. Even the Crumbl worker said it was her favorite. It is a strawberry sugar cookie base with a light glaze, making it less sweet. On top, it has strawberries and streusel crumbs, adding crunch and fruity flavor.
Chocolate Sea Salt Toffee – This cookie has a rich chocolate base and is accompanied by toffee pieces and chocolate chips. It tasted more like a brownie than a cookie, making it quite the mouthful. It would be difficult to eat more than a few bites of this cookie. However, the sea salt aided in balancing the sweetness of the cookie and the toffee added a nice extra pop of flavor!
S’mores Brownie Cookie – This S’mores Brownie Cookie is not available at all Crumbl stores this week but is at the Olympia location. Overall, this was one of the Olympus staff’s favorite flavors! It was half chocolate chip cookie, half brownie with a toasted marshmallow on top. The marshmallow was perfectly gooey, and underneath were melted chocolate chips. This cookie was another very rich cookie that would be hard to eat a lot of, yet very delicious!
Ultimate Peanut Butter – For those who love peanut butter, this cookie is delectable and truly brims with character. The Ultimate Peanut Butter cookie speaks for itself as every aspect consists of peanut butter, from its incorporation into the dough to the presentation of its melted peanut butter drizzle. This decadent dessert was well-baked throughout, and it surely satisfies those with a sweet tooth seeking indulgence, nuttiness and satisfaction.
Milk Chocolate Chip – Finally, for those with analysis paralysis, the Milk Chocolate Chip cookie is always a safe bet. This one received the most praise from the staff of The Olympus, and its rating is backed by the 4.52 star rating from over 500,000 reviews on Crumbl. It’s the warm, soft, chewy, classic cookie that brings a homey feeling. Crumbl does a great job balancing its sweetness with a tinge of salt, making for the timeless flavor we are all used to.
